Skip to main content

Part 0· Status report

SCC — Current Research Status (May 2026, CV-1.17)

This is a living page. It documents the state of Soft Cognitive Cohesion — the research thread I am currently most active on — at the level of granularity that lets a collaborator (or future me) pick up where things stand without re-reading a year of notes.

Last updated: 2026-05-15 (W7 EOD close).   Canonical version: CV-1.17 (sealed 2026-05-15, W7 Day 5 EOD).   Full specification: see the Canonical Spec note.

What SCC is, in one breath

A mathematical theory of how coherent formations emerge prior to discrete objecthood. The primitive is a soft cohesion field

ut:Xt[0,1]u_t : X_t \to [0, 1]

over a relational support space. Objects are a distinguished limit of the formation space, not its starting point. Four independent energy terms govern closure, separation, boundary, and transport; a diagnostic vector d=(Bind,Sep,Inside,Persist)\mathbf{d} = (\mathrm{Bind}, \mathrm{Sep}, \mathrm{Inside}, \mathrm{Persist}) reads off formation state.

Theorem ledger (CV-1.17)

68 Category A + 19 Category B + 6 Category C + 5 Retracted = 98 claims, ~70% fully proved.

The SCC hero theorems and their logical dependencies — 18-node DAG updated to CV-1.11. Foundation (T1, T6, T20), phase + stability (T8-Core, T7-Enhanced, T11, T14), W4 capstone (T-PreObj-1, T-V5b-T), W5 multi-formation bridge (T-L1-F), W6 stochastic foundation (T-P-F-ε₀, T-PF-A1-AR/SDE/GI/PE), W6 boundary + selection (T-OP6-B, T-K-Select-PF/OBS).

Category A — Fully proved (68)

The Cat A roster carries forward the CV-1.5 set (existence T1, closure fixed point T6a/T6b, axiom monotonicity T-A2, phase transition core T8-Core, axiom consistency T20, gradient flow T14, stability duo T3 / T6-Stability, enhanced metastability T7 with p=0.037p = 0.037, Γ\Gamma-convergence T11, the four QM results QM1–4, the Predicate–Energy Bridge, Deep Core Dominance 2b, T-Bind-Proj / T-Bind-Full (both Cat A for all τcl(0,1)\tau_{\mathrm{cl}}\in(0,1) per the Phase 13 upgrade — confirmed by the 2026-05-04 W6 G2 audit which caught a stale Cat B / Cat C shadow in theorem_status.md), Propositions 1.1 / 1.2 and Theorem 3.1, Persistence Threshold Equation, the W4 Pre-Objective Mechanism cluster T-PreObj-1 / T-PreObj-1G / Lemma 4 / F-1 Resolution Corollary, the W4-extended Goldstone result T-V5b-T, and the W5 Day 1 G0 σ-framework supporting structures T-σ-Lemma-1/2/3 + T-σ-Theorem-3) and adds, since 2026-04-27:

  • CV-1.5.1 D-6a Multi-Static (3 Cat A definitional)T-Commitment-14-Multi-Static, T-σ-multi-A-Static, T-σ-multi-D-Static. Defined on the multi-formation interior Σ~MKfield,\widetilde{\Sigma}^{K_{\mathrm{field}},\circ}_M (Option A pragmatic; corners deferred to NQ-248 W7+); σmulti=(σA,σD)\sigma_{\mathrm{multi}} = (\sigma^A, \sigma^D) is a joint invariant under the wreath product Aut(G)SKact\mathrm{Aut}(G) \wr S_{K_{\mathrm{act}}}. The within-formation σ-tuple multi-set is invariant under SKactS_{K_{\mathrm{act}}} permutation in the well-separated regime, and the between-formation cohomology pull-back is a conjugacy-class label in H1(Aut(G)SKact;Stab(u))H^1(\mathrm{Aut}(G) \wr S_{K_{\mathrm{act}}}; \mathrm{Stab}(\mathbf{u}^*)).
  • CV-1.5.1 V5b-T-zero (sub-statement, Cat A def) — Sub-spinodal translation-invariant regime: μGoldV5bTzero=0\mu_{\mathrm{Gold}}^{\mathrm{V5b-T-zero}} = 0 exactly (discrete translation orbit on ZLd\mathbb{Z}_L^d). Replaces the V5b-T' WITHDRAWN entry. Empirical anchor NQ-198f T202/T282T^2_{20}/T^2_{28} with μ0.028|\mu| \le 0.028 within FD numerical noise.
  • CV-1.5.2 T-L1-F (Hard-Bar / Active-Count Bridge) — Cat A conditional under the L1-J regime hypothesis package (P0)(P0)(P11)(P11). First multi-formation canonical Cat A theorem. On a finite graph G=(X,E)G = (X, E) and a shared-pool multi-formation state uΣ~MKfield(G)\mathbf u \in \widetilde\Sigma_M^{K_{\mathrm{field}}}(G), Kbarmin(U(u);G)=Kactε(u)K_{\mathrm{bar}}^{\ell_{\min}}(U(\mathbf u); G) = K_{\mathrm{act}}^\varepsilon(\mathbf u), and the map Abar:AεBars0term(U;G)\mathcal A_{\mathrm{bar}} : A^\varepsilon \to \mathrm{Bars}_0^{\mathrm{term}}(U; G) is a bijection from active slots to dominant terminal H0H_0 bars. NOT a global identity — T-L1-F does NOT solve OP-0005 or OP-0008, and does NOT establish Ksoftϕ=KactK_{\mathrm{soft}}^\phi = K_{\mathrm{act}}.
  • CV-1.6 T-ST-5a (Hard-Depth Topological Locking) — Cat A (W6 D4 Session E, 2026-05-06). A depth-disconnected stereo graph forces K=2K = 2 topologically: ΔE=+\Delta E = +\infty (state-space disconnection). No P-F flag. Gaps G1–G4 closed (Session E): graph topology alone suffices (Lemma 3 not required); merger/decay distinction, A-STRICT assumption, and threshold convention addressed.
  • CV-1.7 T-OP6-B (PersRidge Boundary Equivalence, Phase-Sep Regime) — Cat A conditional under H1–H5 (W6 D4 Session K, 2026-05-06). OP-0006 RESOLVED. Under the phase-separation regime on a connected finite graph: dH(PersRidge(u),Ω)2(α/β)1/2d_H(\mathrm{PersRidge}(u^*), \partial\Omega^*) \leq 2(\alpha/\beta)^{1/2}. B1 topological separator, B2 curved Hausdorff (C<1.37C < 1.37 under H4), B3 stereo conditioning (hard-cut D-ST-1), and B4 ρbd=1/(4ξ)\rho_{\mathrm{bd}} = 1/(4\xi) all closed. exp06: shadow 5/5 ratio 4.09, blur 5/5 ratio 50.8.
  • CV-1.7 T-P-F-ε0 (Gibbs Measure Continuity at ε=0\varepsilon = 0) — Cat A (Session I, 2026-05-06). μεμ0\mu_\varepsilon \Rightarrow \mu_0 weakly as ε0\varepsilon \to 0 under H1–H4. NOT P-F-A1 — does not prove spectral gap, Eyring-Kramers, TT_* existence, or Lions-Sznitman construction.
  • CV-1.8–CV-1.9 P-F-A1 Package I (T-PF-A1-AR / T-PF-A1-SDE / T-PF-A1-GI / T-PF-A1-PE) — all Cat A (Sessions O + P, 2026-05-06). P-F-A1 Package I fully Cat A. (AR) Affine reduction proves Σ~M\widetilde{\Sigma}_M is a bounded convex polytope — polytope SDE well-posed. (SDE) Lions-Sznitman Theorem 1 (convex domain) + Tanaka uniqueness establishes the reflected Langevin SDE on Σ~M\widetilde{\Sigma}_M. (GI) Unique Gibbs invariant measure πT\pi_{T_*} via zero-current + L²(π) kernel argument. (PE) Poincaré inequality λ1(π2/n)exp(osc(E~)/T)\lambda_1 \geq (\pi^2/n)\exp(-\mathrm{osc}(\tilde{\mathcal{E}})/T_*) + exponential ergodicity via Payne-Weinberger + Holley-Stroock. NOT Eyring-Kramers — Package II (explicit rates) remains open (OP-0021, W9+).
  • CV-1.12 T-Temporal-Identity (a) — Existence — Cat A (W7 D1–D2, 2026-05-11/12). Closed via H-SINK: the Bigot–Cazelles–Papadakis (2019) Sinkhorn Lipschitz framework applied in the SCC cost class gives LgLcL_g \leq L_c; combined with P-F-A1 Package I, this discharges the existence half of T-Temporal-Identity. Parts (b) (uniqueness under the margin condition) and (d) (reduction to K=1K = 1) remain, planned for CV-1.18. Part (c) (interior persistence) remains Cat C (OP-0011).
  • CV-1.13 through CV-1.17 — additional Cat A registrations (W7, 2026-05-12 → 2026-05-15). Sub-theorem promotions accompanying the SEAL increments (H-MORSE broadness closure ancillary results, T-Temporal-Identity supporting lemmas, kernel-side regularity riders). Authoritative row-by-row list lives in CV-1.17_SEAL.md (~470 lines) §"Cat A increment audit"; the net W7 Cat A delta is +14.
T-ST-5a — Topological Locking in Phase-Separated Stereo Fields (Cat A, CV-1.6). A depth-disconnected stereo graph forces K = 2: the energy barrier ΔE = +∞ (Goldstone barrier) makes merger structurally impossible. Objects A and B appear close in the image plane but are depth-separated in 3D — each depth-connected component yields exactly one stable formation.
T-OP6-B — PersRidge Boundary Equivalence, Phase-Separation Regime (Cat A, CV-1.7, OP-0006 RESOLVED). The PersRidge locus and the formation boundary ∂Ω* satisfy d_H(PersRidge(u*), ∂Ω*) ≤ 2√(α/β) under H1–H5. Left: 2D plan view with contours; right: 1D cross-section at y = 0 showing the measured separation d_H ≈ 3.06.
P-F-A1 Package I — Stochastic Foundation for T* on Σ̃_M (fully Cat A, CV-1.8–CV-1.9). The four-step canonical chain: AR (bounded convex polytope) → SDE (Lions-Sznitman reflected Langevin) → GI (unique Gibbs invariant measure π(T*)) → PE (Poincaré inequality + explicit TV convergence rate). Package II (Eyring-Kramers explicit rates) remains open (OP-0021, W9+).

Category B — Proved with structural parameter (19)

Original 5 (pre-W6):

  • Barrier exponent γeff0.89\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}} \approx 0.89 — empirical fit, branch / path / manifold conditioned.
  • T-Birth-Parametric (general non-D4D_4 graphs) — supercriticality on D4D_4-symmetric graphs is Cat A; general graphs remain Cat B.
  • T-d_min-Formula — branch-conditioned regression fit.
  • T-Beyond-Weyl — structured spectral perturbation bound; the quantitative 33× factor is config-specific.
  • T-σ-Theorem-4Retroactive Cat A → Cat B at CV-1.5.1 per Critic 7-agent verdict. Continuum-vs-discrete caveat: canonical statement (ii) (μ0=μ1\mu_0 = \mu_1 from A2/A1=4A_2/A_1 = 4) is a continuum-limit prediction not realised on finite discrete grids L16L \le 16 (NQ-187: μ1/μ02\mu_1/\mu_0 \approx 2, p1.03p \approx 1.03). Cat A re-promotion deferred post γ/β/α path closure.

W6 additions (2026-05-06):

  • T-ST-5b (Smooth-Depth Barrier Raising) — Cat B (Session G). Full SCC with Ecl+EsepE_{\mathrm{cl}} + E_{\mathrm{sep}} active raises the merge barrier ~25% over GL-only in the intermediate-β regime (exp02e 6/6 SUPPORTED). GL alone: NULL. Monotone-in-Δz NOT confirmed. Cat A path: monotonicity proof + analytical lower bound on barrier gap.
  • T-P-F-ε0-K (Kramers Exponent Stability under Bernoulli Regularization) — Cat B (Session I). Conditional on H5 (Morse stability): ΔEε=ΔE0+εΔR\Delta E_\varepsilon = \Delta E_0 + \varepsilon \cdot \Delta R; ΓB/ΓA=exp(O(δ))\Gamma_B / \Gamma_A = \exp(O(\delta)) at phase-separated endpoints. NOT P-F-A1. Cat A path: H5 proof + spectral gap.
  • T-K-Select-PF (Equilibrium K-Selection under P-F-A1 Package I) — Cat B (CV-1.10, Session R). Pushforward of πT\pi_{T_*} under KactK_{\mathrm{act}} defines sector probabilities {pK}\{p_K\}; K=argmaxKpKK^* = \arg\max_K p_K. OP-0005-EQ partially resolved. Does NOT resolve OP-0005-DYN (Kramers) or OP-0005-OBS.
  • T-K-Select-OBS (Observation-Conditioned K-Selection) — Cat B (CV-1.11, Session Y). Bayesian posterior πT(O)\pi_{T_*}(\cdot \mid \mathcal{O}) over observation-compatible states selects KobsK^*_{\mathrm{obs}}. exp85 ALL PASSED. OP-0005-OBS partially resolved.
  • D-ST-1/2/3/4/5 (Stereo-SCC definitions) — B candidates (CV-1.6, in canonical.md §3.9–§3.11, §16; formal canonical-row promotion pending). Stereo adjacency (hard/smooth), field space FM(P)\mathcal{F}_M(P), KactK_{\mathrm{act}} as PersComp observable, topological sector / partition function / Kramers rate, backprojection / pullback / prior-likelihood separation.

W7 additions (2026-05-11 → 2026-05-15):

  • T-ACT-KERNEL-COMP→REL (Kernel-Composed Active-Count → Relational Reading, conditional lift) — Cat B (CV-1.15 registered; conditional lift activated at CV-1.17, 2026-05-15). The active-count diagnostic composed through the kernel-side composition operator K\circ_K lifts to a relational reading via the explicit step-additive bijection inherited from T-L1-F. Activated by T-CC-StableK-Kernel; the CV-1.15 forward-reference is now discharged. Cat A path: closing the conditional lift on a thicker stratum than the W7 separator-stability clause.
  • T-CC-StableK-Kernel (Kernel-Composed Compositional Consistency) — Cat B (CV-1.17 SEAL, W7 D5 EOD, 2026-05-15). H-COMP-KERNEL CLOSED. Under the kernel-composition regime (KC1–KC4, mirroring the L1-J multi-formation interior package plus a separator-stability clause), Kactε(u1Ku2)K_{\mathrm{act}}^\varepsilon(\mathbf{u}_1 \circ_K \mathbf{u}_2) is given by the explicit step-additive map on terminal H0H_0 bars, and the active-slot → dominant-bar bijection composes correctly under K\circ_K. Absorbs the CV-1.14 working candidate. Cat A path: thicker-stratum closure of KC3 or residual-separator absorption into the conditional lift on T-ACT-KERNEL-COMP→REL. Authoritative theorem block: canonical.md §13 Cat B (CV-1.17).
  • CV-1.13 through CV-1.17 ancillary Cat B promotions — three additional Cat B rows registered alongside the SEAL increments (H-MORSE broadness leg ancillary results + T-Temporal-Identity supporting Cat B target on the margin-condition direction + a kernel-side regularity rider). Row-by-row list lives in CV-1.17_SEAL.md §"Cat B increment audit". Net W7 Cat B delta: +5.

In addition, T-σ-Multi-1 (Multi-Formation Goldstone-Pair Instability) is a CV-1.5.1 Cat B target (sketch only; Cat A pending NQ-242 anchor). V5b-F-empirical is a Cat B sub-statement target (NQ-198a; quantified C(β=4,ξ0=0.5)13.2±0.4C(\beta=4,\xi_0=0.5) \approx 13.2 \pm 0.4).

Category C — Conditional (6 + Cat C riders + new finding)

  • T-Persist-1(d) — exact-threshold preservation under structural condition β>7α\beta > 7\alpha.
  • T-Persist-Full — composition through (d).
  • T-Persist-K-Sep — well-separated regime conditions (WS, SR). (Per the canonical Erratum 2026-04-07 the Cat-C example list contains T-Persist-K-Sep; cross-file C-vs-B placement is acknowledged drift deferred to a future audit pass per the 2026-05-04 W6 G2 audit note.)
  • T-Persist-K-Weak — weakly-interacting regime conditions (WI, SR, NB-K).
  • T-Persist-K-Unified — parametric (PS, ND, BC′-K, TC-K, SR-Λ), 100% geometric-Lambda agreement on exp46–47.
  • V5b-F (W4-extended new finding, 2026-04-26) — Partial Goldstone on boundary-modified graphs; quantified at CV-1.5.1 as (V5b-F-empirical) Cat B target sub-statement: μGoldV5bFC(β)S/n\mu_{\mathrm{Gold}}^{\mathrm{V5b-F}} \approx C(\beta) \cdot \|\partial S\|/n with C(β=4,ξ0=0.5)13.2±0.4C(\beta = 4, \xi_0 = 0.5) \approx 13.2 \pm 0.4 (NQ-198a 6 corner-saturated, SNR 35). Refutes the Phase 3 heuristic and the Day 3 §4 derivation. Full C(β,ξ0)C(\beta, \xi_0) is open via NQ-198k W6+.
  • T-σ-Lemma-2 sub-statement riders — sub-statements (v) Courant upper bound and (vi) GuG_u-orbit divisibility are Cat C riders within the Cat A entry.
  • T-Temporal-Identity (c) — Interior persistence (W7 D1–D2, CV-1.12) — Cat C, conditional on OP-0011 (transport kernel exact form). Existence half (a) was lifted to Cat A at CV-1.12 via H-SINK; (c) remains the interior-persistence statement that needs an exact-form transport kernel before it can promote.

Retracted (5)

  • Theorem 3.3 (general τ\tau form of rˉ0\bar r_0) — falsified.
  • T-Merge (c) / T-Merge (d) / T-Merge (e) — merge path manifold error.
  • K-Saddle Conjecture — pre-v2.1 retraction.

A 5/5 clean sweep on the five single-formation predictions (historical record):

#PredictionOutcome
P1Contractionproved
P2Independenceproved
P3Enhanced dwellproved (p = 0.037)
P4Path dependenceproved
P5Sep-before-Insideproved

Open Problems Catalog (post-W5 + 2026-05-04 unified)

Note on the catalog file. Until 2026-05-04 the project carried two files: THEORY/canonical/theorem_status.md (theorem index) and THEORY/canonical/open_problems.md (OP catalog). They had drifted into using two incompatible OP-ID systems. On 2026-05-04 the OP catalog was merged into theorem_status.md as a unified Open Problems Catalog section, and open_problems.md was deleted. Do not reference open_problems.md — it no longer exists. All OP body content (Statement, Evidence, Resolution mechanism, Sub-item tables, References, Statistics, Critical Path) now lives under theorem_status.md §Open Problems Catalog.

The W4 close (2026-04-24) reduced the Critical count from 3 to 0 by SPLIT-RESOLVING OP-0001 (F-1 K=2 vacuity), LAYER-CLARIFYING OP-0002 (M-1 K=1 preference), and SIDESTEPPING OP-0003 (MO-1 Morse inapplicability). Those resolutions are unchanged. The post-W5 active catalog is:

OP-IDProblemSeverityStatus
OP-0001F-1: K=2 vacuous(was Critical) ResolvedSPLIT-RESOLVED (2026-04-24) via T-PreObj-1 (i) + T-Merge (b)
OP-0002M-1: K=1 preferred(was Critical) ResolvedLAYER-CLARIFIED (2026-04-24) — proved theorem misframed
OP-0003MO-1: Morse fails(was High) SidesteppedSIDESTEPPED for single-formation σ scope; re-activation rider added at CV-1.5.1 on D-6b approval or NQ-248 multi-formation Morse work
OP-0004Type A/B ClassificationHighRETRACTED (empirically invalidated; exp65 0/4 Type B observed)
OP-0005K-Selection mechanismHigh3-WAY SPLIT (W6): EQ PARTIALLY RESOLVED via T-K-Select-PF Cat B (CV-1.10); OBS PARTIALLY RESOLVED via T-K-Select-OBS Cat B (CV-1.11); DYN OPEN (Eyring-Kramers explicit rates, Package II, W9+)
OP-0006Boundary precision(was High) RESOLVEDRESOLVED (W6 D4) via T-OP6-B Cat A — PersRidge Boundary Equivalence under H1–H5 in the phase-separation regime
OP-0008σ^A K-jump inheritance non-determinismHighOPEN (CV-1.5.1, W5 Day 4); Path B σ-rich + Φ-rich Cat B target
OP-0009Multi-Formation Ontological FoundationsHighOPEN (CV-1.5.1, W5 Day 4; 7 sub-items); 1/7 RESOLVED via Commitment 16 (OP-0009-K); 6/7 PARTIALLY (OP-0009-F marginal clarification via Φres\Phi_{\mathrm{res}} class restriction in W5 Day 7)
OP-0010Bind generalizationMediumOPEN (T-Bind-Proj/Full now Cat A per Phase 13 — see W6 G2 audit; OP-0010 retains for any further generalization questions)
OP-0011Transport kernel exact formMediumTENTATIVE
OP-0012Persistence compositionMediumOPEN
OP-0013Closure operator convergence rateMediumOPEN
OP-0020Dynamic topology (out of scope)Lowseed (formerly OP-0007 in the pre-2026-05-04 numbering)
OP-0021Stochastic dynamicsLowUNDER INVESTIGATION (exp54–exp59 Kramers rate theory)
OP-0022Continuous-time limitLowseed
OP-HMORSE-BROADNESSH-MORSE broadness (kernel-side)MediumCLOSED (W7 D3, 2026-05-12) — H-MORSE partially closed; closure leg for the kernel-side broadness obstruction
OP-HMORSE-IDXMorse-stability indexMediumOPEN (W7 D3) — H-MORSE residual sub-item
OP-HMORSE-SGAPSpectral-gap lower boundMediumOPEN (W7 D3) — H-MORSE residual; Cat B path on Package II first sub-result
OP-HMORSE-KREGKernel-side regularityMediumOPEN (W7 D3) — H-MORSE residual
OP-HMORSE-MEASResidual measure-theoretic conditionsMediumOPEN (W7 D3) — H-MORSE residual
OP-HMORSE-STRPStructural-parameter dependenceMediumOPEN (W7 D3) — H-MORSE residual
OP-HMORSE-QUANTQuantification riderLowOPEN (W7 D3) — H-MORSE residual; non-blocking
OP-SB1-084Stereo-boundary registration (sub-item 084)LowOPEN (W7 hygiene, 2026-05-15) — tracked but not yet substantively addressed

Net post-W7 active count: 3 High + 9 Medium + 4 Low = 16 active OPs (plus 6 closed/resolved entries OP-0001 / OP-0002 / OP-0003 / OP-0004 / OP-0006 / OP-HMORSE-BROADNESS retained for traceability). The W7 medium count grew because the H-MORSE umbrella was deliberately decomposed into seven separable sub-items (1 closed, 5 medium open, 1 low open) — a finer registration that lets each sub-item move independently, at the cost of a higher catalog count. OMS sub-OPs OP-OMS-032b / 033b / 034b / 034c are non-blocking formalities tracked in THEORY/working/observer_moduli/open_problems.md.

OP-0005 — Three-Way Split of the K-Selection Problem (CV-1.10, 2026-05-06). The original single open problem is now decomposed into three independent branches: EQ (equilibrium K-selection via partition function, Cat B partial), OBS (observation-conditioned K-selection via OMS-2.0, Cat B partial), and DYN (dynamical K-selection via Eyring-Kramers, open — P-F-A1 Package II, W9+). Full resolution requires Package II (OP-0021).
F-1 (K=2 vacuity) split-resolved (W4, 2026-04-24). Both layers are Category A: pure E_bd via T-Merge (b) (pre-existing) and full SCC via T-PreObj-1 (i) (W4 new). The dichotomy is dissolved.
CN15 — Static / Dynamic Separation. The conceptual key that allowed F-1 / M-1 to dissolve at W4 close: the static global minimum on pure E_bd and the dynamic protocol-endpoint observables under full SCC are quantities of different layers; they need not match.

Most recent canonical edits (CV-1.5.2 → CV-1.17)

  • 2026-05-02 (W5 Day 6): T-L1-F merged Cat A conditional. CV-1.5.1 → CV-1.5.2. 45A → 46A. 61 claims.
  • 2026-05-04 (W6 Day 1): T-Bind Cat A confirmed; T-σ-Theorem-4 continuum caveat added; open_problems.md merged into theorem_status.md (deleted). Strategic plan redesigned.
  • 2026-05-06 (W6 Day 4, Sessions A–Y): CV-1.5.2 → CV-1.6 → … → CV-1.11 in a single work session. Net: +8A +9B = +17 claims. Key promotions: T-ST-5a Cat A (CV-1.6); T-OP6-B Cat A + T-P-F-ε0 Cat A (CV-1.7, OP-0006 RESOLVED); P-F-A1 Package I fully Cat A (CV-1.8–CV-1.9); T-K-Select-PF Cat B (CV-1.10, OP-0005-EQ partial); T-K-Select-OBS Cat B (CV-1.11, OP-0005-OBS partial).
  • 2026-05-07 (W6 Day 5): DECLARATION.md DECL-1.0 (6 epistemological commitments) + hypothesis_tree.md HT-3.0 (dependency graph, critical path for CV-1.12) created.
  • 2026-05-08 (W6 Day 6, Sessions 7–8): OMS-2.0 promoted from Conditional Accepted → Accepted — Full. OP-OMS-034 CLOSED (temporal Gcwtemp={e}G_{\mathrm{cw}}^{\mathrm{temp}} = \{e\} confirmed; 19-branch Δ³ map). Appendix OMS §A–§M (Static + Temporal) added to canonical.md.
  • 2026-05-08 (W6 EOD): theorem_status.md header + canonical.md DEVELOPMENT NOTICE updated to CV-1.11 state. Weekly summary written. Targeted CV-1.12 via H-SINK (T-Temporal-Identity a/b/d, +3A, Bigot–Cazelles–Papadakis route).
  • 2026-05-11/12 (W7 D1–D2): CV-1.12 — H-SINK closed via Bigot–Cazelles–Papadakis Sinkhorn Lipschitz framework (LgLcL_g \leq L_c in SCC cost class). T-Temporal-Identity (a) Cat A. Parts (b)(d) deferred to CV-1.18.
  • 2026-05-12 (W7 D3): CV-1.13 SEAL — cross-file audit of CV-1.12. OP-HMORSE-BROADNESS CLOSED (H-MORSE partially closed via the kernel-side broadness leg); six new OP-HMORSE-* sub-items registered.
  • 2026-05-13/14 (W7 D4): CV-1.14 reserved (forward-reference to kernel-composed compositional consistency working candidate). CV-1.15 SEAL + CV-1.16 SEAL — intermediate audits; T-ACT-KERNEL-COMP→REL registered with explicit forward-reference (conditional lift queued).
  • 2026-05-15 (W7 D5 EOD): CV-1.17 SEALT-CC-StableK-Kernel Cat B absorbed the CV-1.14 working candidate; H-COMP-KERNEL CLOSED; T-ACT-KERNEL-COMP→REL conditional lift activated; CV-1.15 forward-reference discharged. Stage A Hygiene (6 in-place edits) + Stage B SEAL. CV-1.17_SEAL.md (~470 lines) certifies CV-1.14 reserved-version absorption, non-overclaim audit, and CV-1.18 target list. First _archive/ cohort (working/parking/_archive/working_parked_2026-05/, 14 files). HT-3.7 → HT-3.8. Net W7: +14A +5B +1C = +20 claims. CV-1.11 → CV-1.17. 78 → 98 claims.
  • 2026-05-15 (W7 EOD): theorem_status.md header + canonical.md frontmatter + release-state heading synchronized to CV-1.17 state. Weekly summary written at THEORY/logs/weekly/2026-05-W2/weekly_summary.md. Next target: CV-1.18 via T-Temporal-Identity (b)(d) + σ-inheritance OP-0008 partial + P-F-A1 Package II first sub-result.

Implementation

scc/ package — 215 passed + 1 xfailed (216 collected)

The 175 → 215 jump came from test modules added on 2026-04-28 (test_outside_spinodal_override.py) and 2026-04-30 (test_aut_g_stabilizer.py, test_sigma_rich.py, test_sigma_rich_integration.py); earlier CHANGELOG entries that say "196/196" were corrected by the 2026-05-04 audit. The authoritative measurement is 215 passed, 1 xfailed in 231.57s.

moduleresponsibility
graph.pyGraphState — sparse adjacency, Laplacian, Fiedler, row-normalised PP
params.pyParameterRegistry — constraint validation (acl<4a_{\mathrm{cl}} < 4, spinodal range, βcrit\beta_{\mathrm{crit}})
operators.pyclosure, distinction, aggregation, resolvent — with exact JVP for gradient
energy.pyEcl,Esep,Ebd\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{cl}}, \mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{sep}}, \mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{bd}} with FD-verified gradients (1e-9)
optimizer.pyfind_formation() — semi-implicit projected GD on Σm\Sigma_m with BB step
diagnostics.pyDiagnosticVector — Bind / Sep / Inside / Persist
multi.pyK-field architecture (I9), inter-formation repulsion, coupled transport
transport.pytemporal transport kernel, Sinkhorn partial OT, persist_transport

The pipeline is canonical: graph → params → operators → energy → optimizer → diagnostics.

Experiments — exp1 through exp97 + W4-extended + W5 numerical

The numbered experiment series runs exp1 through exp97, plus the W4-extended E-0090 through E-0097 cluster anchoring T-PreObj / T-V5b-T / σ supporting structures, plus the W5 numerical work that does not consume an expN slot:

  • NQ-141 R23 32×32 — single-graph σ empirical Cat A anchor for T-σ-Lemma-2 / Theorem-3 (W4-04-25).
  • NQ-170c 2D torus L = 20 ζ = 0.5 overlap 0.97 — anchors T-σ-Lemma-3 Goldstone–ℓ=1 saturation (W4-04-26).
  • NQ-187 σ-Theorem-4 scaling testL{4,8,16}L \in \{4, 8, 16\}, ϵ{0.001..0.1}\epsilon \in \{0.001..0.1\} on discrete D4D_4 free-BC grids; falsified the continuum A2/A1=4A_2/A_1 = 4 degeneracy on finite grids (W6 audit, 2026-05-04).
  • NQ-198a V5b-F empirical scaling — 6 corner-saturated configurations; quantified C(β=4,ξ0=0.5)13.2±0.4C(\beta = 4, \xi_0 = 0.5) \approx 13.2 \pm 0.4 at SNR 35.
  • NQ-198f — V5b-T'-WITHDRAWN (phantom on torus; μ0.028|\mu| \le 0.028 within FD numerical noise).
  • L1-I 439 / 1920 = 22.9% feasible on T202T^2_{20} — empirical anchor for the T-L1-F hypothesis package; best case σb=0.5\sigma_b = 0.5, δ=0.02\delta = 0.02, r=0r = 0, min=0.10\ell_{\min} = 0.10 raw_gaussian.
  • L1-H2 stress 5/5 + L1-J PO-1 6/6 — additional T-L1-F anchors.

Promotion pipeline (3-stage, unified 2026-05-04)

THEORY/logs/daily/YYYY-MM-DD/         (raw chronological record)
                ↓ reorganize by topic
THEORY/working/<topic>.md             (active theory development)
                ↓ proof + review + tests
THEORY/canonical/canonical.md         (authoritative — one-way only)

The earlier 4-stage weekly rotation pipeline (working / topic.md → logs/weekly/YYYY-MM-W<n>/weekly_draft_storming.md → weekly_summary.md → canonical.md) was retired on 2026-05-04 as part of the Pass 2 audit — THEORY/canonical/README.md and THEORY/logs/README.md were rewritten to describe the 3-stage pipeline that the rest of the meta-docs (CLAUDE.md, CONVENTIONS.md, working/README.md, MAIN_PROMPT.md) already used. Weekly summaries are now retained as retrospective synthesis only and are no longer a promotion-pipeline stage.

Repository structure (2026-04-20 reorganisation, 2026-05-04 canonical contents)

The current repository structure is a clean CODE / THEORY split:

  • CODE/ — executable assets: the scc/ package (12 modules), pytest suite (215 passed + 1 xfailed), experiments/ (exp1–exp97 plus W4-extended E-0090–E-0097), papers/ (currently IEEEtran.cls + figures/ + generate_figures.py; the two paper drafts were deleted on 2026-05-04 and will be rewritten from scratch later), and scripts/.
  • THEORY/ — theory documents with strict three-way separation:
    • canonical/ — authoritative; canonical.md + theorem_status.md + figures/ + README.md (the previously-separate open_problems.md was merged into theorem_status.md on 2026-05-04 and deleted). Promoted content only.
    • working/ — in-progress development; one file per topic. Notable current resident: the L-M Soft-Count Corollary working draft at THEORY/working/MF/ksoft_kact_bridge_L1M_soft_count_corollary.md (Cat B sketched, R-1 / R-2 / R-3 audit items pending; CV-1.6 promotion target via the L1-M-AUDIT cycle).
    • logs/ — chronological journal; daily/ + weekly/ + monthly/.

The 2026-04-12 "Research OS" reboot — an 8-layer structure with numbered 00_meta/07_archive/ directories and 5-role daily logs — was tried for four days, collapsed under its own scaffolding on 2026-04-16, and was archived on 2026-04-18. The current CLAUDE.md policy explicitly forbids re-introducing the numbered-directory / 5-role / per-item registry structure. The honest "tried and abandoned" record lives in _archive/research_os_2026-04-12/.

W7 outcomes + next session plan

W7 is closed (2026-05-11 → 2026-05-15). W7 carried three workstreams; all are resolved or audited:

  • G1 — H-SINK closure (CV-1.12 target)DONE (2026-05-11/12). Bigot–Cazelles–Papadakis Sinkhorn Lipschitz framework discharged in the SCC cost class; T-Temporal-Identity (a) Cat A. Parts (b)(d) deferred to CV-1.18.
  • G2 — H-COMP-KERNEL closure (compositional consistency)DONE (2026-05-15, CV-1.17 SEAL). T-CC-StableK-Kernel Cat B; T-ACT-KERNEL-COMP→REL conditional lift activated; CV-1.15 forward-reference discharged.
  • G3 — working/parking/ inventory and archiveDONE (2026-05-15). 14 files moved into _archive/working_parked_2026-05/; first instantiation of the _archive/ root.

A fourth workstream — auditing a user-proposed primitive extension (zt/S0/Kreadz_t / S_0 / K_{\mathrm{read}}) — was carried through six audit stages and resolved as Decision C (defer, archive proposal trace): V=0V = 0, archive-pattern match 6 / 6. The proposal lives in _archive/proposals_2026-05/zt_S0_Kread.md; no canonical change.

Net W7 result (entry → exit):

Entry (05-11)Exit (05-15)
Canonical versionCV-1.11CV-1.17 (sealed)
Claims78 (54A/14B/5C/5R)98 (68A/19B/6C/5R)
H-COMP-KERNELworking candidateCLOSED — Cat B
H-MORSEopenpartially closed (broadness leg)
_archive/ cohorts01 (14 files, 2026-05)
SEAL documentsCV-1.13+ CV-1.15, CV-1.16, CV-1.17
HT versionHT-3.0HT-3.8
Theory navigationHT-3.0 + DECLARATION.mdHT-3.8 + DECLARATION.md
pytest215+1xfailed215+1xfailed (clean)
W6 Canonical Timeline (2026-05-04 to 2026-05-08): CV-1.6 → CV-1.11, 78 claims (54A / 14B / 5C / 5R, ~69% proved). Key milestones: T-ST-5a Cat A (D1), T-OP6-B + OP-0006 RESOLVED (D3), P-F-A1 Package I Cat A (D4), T-K-Select-PF/OBS Cat B + OP-0005 3-way split (D4), DECL-1.0 + HT-3.0 (D5), OMS-2.0 Accepted — Full (D6).

Next session — CV-1.18 (three queued candidates):

  1. T-Temporal-Identity (b) and (d). Margin-condition tightening on (b); reduction-to-K=1K=1 on (d). +2 A expected.
  2. σ-inheritance OP-0008 partial. A Cat B target on Path B (σ-rich + Φ-rich) is the most likely shape.
  3. Eyring–Kramers Package II first sub-result. With H-MORSE broadness closed, the next-easiest dependency is the spectral-gap lower bound (Cat B path); full Package II remains W9+.

Monitoring items: H-SINK Lipschitz constant fine-tune (quantitative tightening of LgLcL_g \leq L_c, no new theorem row) and OP-SB1-084 (registered in W7 hygiene, not yet substantively addressed). Entry point: THEORY/canonical/hypothesis_tree.md (HT-3.8) §CV-1.18 targets + CV-1.17_SEAL.md §"CV-1.18 target list".

Twelve iterations of method (historical)

The path from brainstorming to the current spec can be read as twelve distinct iterations (this list is unchanged from the 2026-04-27 snapshot — it is a historical retrospective, not a live count):

IterFocusKey output
I1Brainstorming (10 rounds)44 settled points
I2Deep mathematics12 theorems proved
I3Implementation designAlgorithm + module specs
I4ExtensionsGestalt mapping, 10 predictions
I5Vulnerability audit17 vulnerabilities found
I6Spec rewriteCanonical Spec v2.0
I7Temporal theoryT-Persist-1, Sep identity
I8Code + experimentsscc/ package, 89 tests
I9Multi-formationK-field architecture decided
I10PublicationTwo paper outlines + drafts
I11Transport implementationtransport.py, T-Persist verified
I12Multi-temporalT-Persist-K-Sep/Weak, regime classification

The W4 / W4-extended / W5 / W6 work since 2026-04-19 is best read off the weekly summaries in THEORY/logs/weekly/ rather than as a thirteenth iteration; the iteration numbering froze at I12.

Papers on this track

Dedicated SCC manuscripts are currently not in the working tree — the two earlier drafts (paper1_math.tex, paper2_cogsci.tex) were deleted from CODE/papers/ on 2026-05-04 and will be rewritten from scratch. When they reappear, they will appear in the papers index. In the meantime, the closest published-side work is the Axiomatic Framework for Understanding Relations via Gauge-Invariant Cohomology, which establishes the relational substrate underpinning SCC.