Skip to main content

χONN

ORTSF Delay-Margin Certificate

An honestly scoped ORTSF control note: a model-level phase-margin gate implemented in a guarded pipeline, plus a single-mode scalar delay-independent certificate. Multimode and deployed-controller stability remain open.

updated 486 words2 min read

Rewritten 2026-07-10 against onn_ws/ONN. The earlier version stated τmax=177  μs\tau_{\max} = 177\;\mu\text{s} "for 3M-node networks" and derived stability from a cohomological Lyapunov function — neither of which is in the source. The old published control numbers (dtmax=52 ms\text{dt}_{\max} = 52\text{ ms}, phase margin 28°28°) are not regenerable and are dropped. The two results below are the narrower model-level statements supported by the current source.

Statement (delay margin)

For the constructed linear plant model G(s)=C(sI+M)1BG(s) = C(sI + M)^{-1}B with M=LF+μΠHM = L_F + \mu\,\Pi_{H^\perp} (poles (λi+μ)-(\lambda_i + \mu), dominant pole p=λ2+μp = \lambda_2 + \mu), and the integrating controller model C(s)=K/sC(s)=K/s, the phase margin is

φPM=π2arctan ⁣(ωcp),\varphi_{\mathrm{PM}} = \frac{\pi}{2} - \arctan\!\left(\frac{\omega_c}{p}\right),

and that modeled loop has the delay margin

Δtmax=φPMωc.\Delta t_{\max} = \frac{\varphi_{\mathrm{PM}}}{\omega_c}.

This model-level gate is implemented and tested in the GuardedORTSFPipeline: it computes Δtmax\Delta t_{\max} from the spectrum, admits commands while delay<Δtmax\text{delay} < \Delta t_{\max}, and falls back to a zero-velocity command at or above the threshold. The guarded path is not the default deployed control path, so this is not evidence of physical-system or deployed-controller stability.

Single-mode delayed recurrence (sufficient, conservative)

Separately, consider the scalar additive delayed-feedback reduction on one dominant inconsistent mode,

et+1=ρetKcetd.e_{t+1} = \rho e_t - K_c e_{t-d}.

For this recurrence, with ρ=max{1ηλ2,1ηλmax}\rho = \max\{|1-\eta\lambda_2|,|1-\eta\lambda_{\max}|\}, the condition

ρ+Kc<1\rho + |K_c| < 1

is sufficient for all characteristic roots to remain inside the unit disk for every integer delay d1d\geq1. This is a delay-independent result for the stated single-mode scalar model. It is not the product-form general feedback small-gain condition, and it does not certify the full interconnected ORTSF loop.

Honest scope

  • The two results use different models. The first is a linearized plant with an integrating controller; the second is an additive scalar delayed recurrence. Neither is a general nonlinear closed-loop theorem.
  • The scalar result does not cover coupled modes or the shipped controller. The multimode bound through the actuation operator BB is open, and the abstract KcK_c has not been mapped to the fabric's multi-joint PD gains and interpolation law.
  • The guarded path is not the deployed default. Its threshold behavior is tested, but end-to-end deployment and physical validation remain open.
  • This is systems completion, not novelty. Both statements use standard control arguments and are presented as scoped engineering certificates.
  • The phase-margin formula is not a λ2\lambda_2-only bound. The spectrum enters the modeled pole pp, while the crossover ωc\omega_c also depends on the controller design. No cohomological invariant supplies the margin.
  • No numeric bound is claimed as a physical result. The certificate is symbolic and enforced; the only concrete figure in the source is an illustrative Δtmax=0.49 s\Delta t_{\max} = 0.49\text{ s} in an end-to-end demo.